320 cities · 12,480+ places · updated weekly
See what's trending →
Add your place
Ice Cream Shop Menu 4.5 · 615 reviews

McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor Menu

New York, United States

Menu last updated: Jun 25, 2026

The menu blends classic and creative flavors suited for solo diners and groups alike, reflecting a casual and cozy atmosphere. Dietary options and food tags....

View Restaurant Get Directions Call
View McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor Photo Menu 1 View McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor Photo Menu 2 Zoom McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor Photo Menu 3 View all photos

Restaurant

McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor

Cuisine

Ice Cream Shop

Location

New York

Rating

4.5 / 5

Profile

View restaurant

Most ordered

The items regulars come back for at McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor.

Banana Split

Banana Split
Dark Chocolate

Dark Chocolate
Matty's M&M Madness

Matty's M&M Madness
Dishes Ice Cream

Dishes Ice Cream
Disfrutando de Un Rico Helado

Disfrutando de Un Rico Helado
طبق حلويات آيس كريم

طبق حلويات آيس كريم
Full menu

Full Menu

Browse the complete McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor menu with current prices and options.

Ice Cream Sandwiches

  • 6 Ice Cream Sandwiches

    $10.50

    Six Ice Cream Sandwiches Either Vanilla, Chocolate or Twist.

Mains

  • Dishes

    $5.85

  • Waffle Bowl

    $7.75

    3 super sized scoops.

  • Pints And Quarts To Go

    $7.99

    Quarts and Pints of Ice Cream!

Kids Corner

  • Cinderella Sundae

    $5.85

    1 scoop strawberry or vanilla ice cream, strawberry topping, whipped cream, rainbow sprinkles, and a cherry.

  • James' Carmel Creation

    $5.85

    Vanilla soft ice cream lots of caramel, chocolate ships, and whipped cream topped with a caramel candy.

  • Matty's M&M Madness

    $5.85

    Vanilla soft ice cream, lots and lots of mini M&M's whipped cream, and more M&M's.

  • Jimmy Junior Sundae

    $5.85

    1 scoop, 1 topping, whipped cream, sprinkles, and a cherry.

  • Ann Marie's Angel Sundae

    $5.85

    Twist ice cream, chocolate syrup, whipped cream, chocolate sprinkles, salted with a chocolate.

  • Dinosaur Sundae

    $5.85

    Mint chunk or vanilla ice cream. Hot fudge topping, whipped cream, sprinkles and a cherry.

Sundae Specialities

  • Billy's Super Sized Sundae

    $14.95

    6 ice creams, 4 toppings, lots of whipped cream, sprinkles, and a cherry. A quart sized sundae.

  • Mom Mc Nulty's Traditional Style

    $8.50

    Your choice of ice cream, topping, whipped cream, sprinkles, and a cherry.

  • The Long Islander

    $9.50

    Creamy soft vanilla ice cream with layered toppings of butterfingers, chocolate chips, and hot fudge topped with whipped cream, sprinkles, and a cherry.

  • Peanut Butter Lover's Delight

    $9.50

    3 icecreams, peanut butter topping, reeses pieces, peanut butter cups, whipped cream sprinkles, and a cherry.

  • The Miller Place CMP

    $9.50

    3 ice creams, topped with chocolate syrup, marshmallow, peanuts, lots of whipped cream, sprinkles, and a cherry.

  • Banana Boat

    $10.50

    3 ice creams, 3 toppings, fresh banana, whipped cream, sprinkles, and a cherry.

  • Strawberry Shortcake

    $9.50

    Vanilla icecream, strawberry topping, whipped cream, lots of vanilla crunch, and a cherry.

  • Colosso Sundae

    $10.50

    3 ice creams, 3 toppings, whipped cream, sprinkles, and a cherry served in our waffle bowl.

Refreshing Cold Beverage Desserts

  • Milk Shake Float

    $7.99

    Creamy shake with a large scoop of icecream added.

  • Creamy Milk Shake

    $7.75

    Choose your flavor made thick and rich.

  • Malted Milk Shake

    $7.99

    Choose your flavor and add old fashion malted milk made to perfection.

Dietary & food tags

What this menu is great for

Dietary & Food Tags

Ice Cream Kids Friendly Shakes & Floats Quick Visit Coffee Available Wheelchair Accessible Group Friendly

Dietary and allergen information may vary by item. Confirm details with the restaurant before ordering.

Plan a visit

Visiting McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor

Open daily with dine-in, takeout, and delivery. Typical visit lasts about 15 minutes. Parking and wheelchair accessibility are available for a convenient experience.

153 N Country Rd, Miller Place, NY 11764, United States
Get Directions Call View Restaurant Profile

Today at McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor

  • Opens at 12:00 PM
  • +1 631-474-3543
  • Delivery · Onsite services · Takeout · Dine-in
  • Credit cards · Debit cards · NFC mobile payments
About the menu

About the McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor Menu

Menu Sections: Sundae Specialities, Mains, Kids Corner, Ice Cream Sandwiches, Cold Beverage Desserts Popular Dishes: Banana Split, Matty's M&M Madness, Dark Chocolate Typical Visit Duration: 15 minutes Location: Miller Place, NY Payments: Credit, Debit, NFC mobile payments

The menu at this ice cream shop offers a diverse selection of treats split into well-curated sections such as Sundae Specialities, Mains, and Kids Corner.

Featured dishes like Banana Split and Matty's M&M Madness stand out among various sundaes and shakes available. Customers can also choose from ice cream sandwiches and cold beverage desserts like malted milk shakes.

The menu blends classic and creative flavors suited for solo diners and groups alike, reflecting a casual and cozy atmosphere. Dietary options and food tags highlight accessibility and kid-friendly selections.

Menu items, prices, and availability may change. Check directly with the parlor for the most current details.
Photos

A visual look at McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor - items, ambience, and dining space.

2 photos
McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor Menu 1 McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor Menu 2

The Kids Corner section features treats like Matty's M&M Madness and Cinderella Sundae designed with children in mind.

Some items have been noted to include gluten-free ice cream options, but confirming with the shop is recommended for dietary restrictions.

Yes, the parlor offers delivery, takeout, and dine-in services with no table service available.

Popular dishes include Banana Split, Dark Chocolate sundaes, and ice cream specials featured in the Sundae Specialities and Kids Corner menu sections.

Wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, and restrooms are provided to accommodate visitors with accessibility requirements.

Payments via credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments are accepted.

More menus to browse

Similar restaurants with menus

Other Ice Cream Shop in New York with menus on Locallya.

Buona Caffe Artisan Roasted Coffee
Coffee Shop

Buona Caffe Artisan Roasted Coffee Menu

520 Reynolds St, Augusta, GA 30901, United States

4.3 View Menu
U3 NUTRITION
Cafe

U3 NUTRITION Menu

122 N Reading Rd, Ephrata, PA 17522, United States

4.8 View Menu
Restaurante bife de chorizo
Restaurant

Restaurante bife de chorizo Menu

RN7, Mendoza, Argentina

4.5 View Menu
Old Fung Tea House
Dim Sum Restaurant

Old Fung Tea House Menu

Treasure Garden Block B, 1 On Chee Rd, Tai Po, Hong Kong

3.9 View Menu
Miller & Carter Steakhouse
Steak House

Miller & Carter Steakhouse Menu

Mansfield Rd, Nottingham NG5 8PJ, United Kingdom

4.7 View Menu
For business owners

Own or manage this restaurant?

Help customers find the latest menu by updating dishes, prices, photos, and availability. Keep your McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor listing accurate on Locallya.

  • Free to claim & verify
  • Edit menu items anytime
  • Update prices & photos
  • Respond to customer reviews
Claim this listing Suggest a menu update